My theory (please credit me if shared) :
Ok one of the biggest questions on a su fans mind right now is “who did pearl belong to?” And “who really shattered pink?” I believe that pearl in fact DID NOT belong to one diamond - but all four mostly. After white saw our pearls imperfection, she cast her out as an executioner for the court system on homeworld (cred. To the roundtable on YouTube , I think). When pink was finally lent her own colony, they sent their most dangerous pearl to protect the childish diamond. More proof to this theory that she “belonged” to pink is - how did pearl get to earth? Surely when the diamonds noticed that our pearl was outspoken and quirky, they didn’t let her out of their sight, so she wouldn’t be able to sneak to earth via warp (+ the diamonds would’ve followed her and shattered her for escaping). Pearl must have had some sort of easy way to, A. meet Rose quartz (who was made on earth) and B. be able to fight in the war without escaping HW. My second point is that pearl most likely shattered pink under roses influence. Rose obviously found her as her as a threat to the earth. Pearl wanted to shatter her and take full responsibility and die for rose, but she wouldn’t allow it. Rose had pearl shapeshifter to herself and do the shattering. Pearl now is so horrified with what she had done that she can no longer shaped change without feeling guilty. As for pearl silencing herself - I’m not really sure if it was a diamond power or some other gem we have yet to meet. Hope you guys liked it and if you want to add anything let me know!
Tags : #pinkdiamondsu #pinkdiamond #whitediamond #whitediamondsu #bluediamond #bluediamondsu #yellowdiamond #yellowdiamondsu #stevenuniversetheory #supearl #pearltheory #crystalgems #rosequartzsu #rosequartz