"Handsy" and inconsistent? You might be trying to control the swing with your dominate hand, which is the trail hand for most golfers. Watch my right hand closely in this drill. My palm is touching, but my fingers are off the club for the entire swing to keep my right hand out of the swing. For golfers that rely on their right hand/arm for power and control, this is a great drill because it teaches more body and lead arm control. That can help take the hands out and improve consistency. I would recommend half swings at first and work up to 3/4 swings.