494 Photos

» LOG IN to write comment.

imhereforpll I could tell this was Shay because of the lips. #IsThatWeird? #ShayMitchell #ShayMitch #ButtahBenzo #ShayButtah 2w

» LOG IN to write comment.

» LOG IN to write comment.

Normal Shay Is Perfection

» LOG IN to write comment.

» LOG IN to write comment.

Normal ShayButtah And Ash benzo
buttahflavored Shay, Ash, and Lucy at a party around 2k11 I think? #buttahbenzo #shaybuttah #shaymitchell #ashleybenson #lucyhale #emily #hanna #aria 3mon

» LOG IN to write comment.

perfectionis_shaym @shaym baby on her #ShayButtah bike happy earth day before it hits midnight @shaym 3mon

» LOG IN to write comment.

Normal Pretty Little Liars
pllspoilers Let's all fangirl together! Very sweet yeah?? #HappyBirthdayShayMitchell #ShayButtah #ShayMitchell 3mon

» LOG IN to write comment.

Normal Pretty Little Liars
pllspoilers HAPPY HAPPY BIRTHDAY to my favorite liar Shannon Ashley Garcia Mitchell! I'm still hoping I would meet you someday @shaym #ShayMitchell #ShayButtah #Shayonce #Shaym 3mon

» LOG IN to write comment.

Normal Tyannah LaShae Bowe

» LOG IN to write comment.

Normal Pretty Little Liars
pllspoilers Shay would love this if she sees it. We all know she loves @beyonce #Shayonce #ShayMitchell #ShayButtah @shaym 4mon

» LOG IN to write comment.